50 But when the deflation is severe, falling asset prices along with debtor bankruptcies lead to a decline in the nominal value of assets on bank balance sheets. = When debt issuance reaches new peaks, it can deflate the value of real currency. Non-recourse provisions can help a borrower in distress while full recourse provisions require them to pay additional capital to the bank if the value of their collateral does not cover its credit balance. Given the perceived political difficulties in debt relief and the suggested inefficacy of alternative courses of action, proponents of debt deflation are either pessimistic about solutions, expecting extended, possibly decades-long depressions, or believe that private debt relief (and related public debt relief – de facto sovereign debt repudiation) will result from an extended period of inflation. (2007) "Learn From the Fall of Rome, U.S. Similarly invoking Minsky, in 2011 Charles J. Whalen wrote, "the global economy has recently experienced a classic Minsky crisis - one with intertwined cyclical and institutional (structural) dimensions."[19]. A 24/7 chat room where veteran traders from around the world share opportunities and actionable ideas in real time In order to apply this to financial markets, which involve transactions across time in the form of debt – receiving money now in exchange for something in future – he made two further assumptions:[4]. High volumes of debt and high rates of default have a deflationary effect on a borrower’s secured mortgage collateral. No. If prices and wages are falling, then deflation causes the real value of debt to increase. % Deflation also makes the burden of debt heavier, as the same fixed dollar amount of a loan … % Mathematical models of debt deflation have recently been developed by post-Keynesian economist Steve Keen. As lower prices make it harder for businesses to pay back a record corporate debt bubble, deflation will trap the economy in a vicious cycle. 73. On the other hand, if the foregoing analysis is correct, it is always economically possible to stop or prevent such a depression simply by reflating the price level up to the average level at which outstanding debts were contracted by existing debtors and assumed by existing creditors, and then maintaining that level unchanged. Empirical support and modern mainstream interest, harv error: no target: CITEREFFisher1930 (, Pilkington, Philip (February 24, 2014). "The Financial Instability Hypothesis". In the context of this quote and the development of his theory and the central role it places on debt, it is of note that Fisher was personally ruined due to his having assumed debt due to his over-confidence prior to the crash, by buying stocks on margin. Another way to think of deflation is that the real value of debt increases. The Massive Debt Deflation Risk Murray Gunn • February 18, 2020. In options markets, the "Greeks" refer to various measurements of how valuations move. Empirical support for the Bernanke transmission mechanism in the post–World War II economic activity is weaker. The offers that appear in this table are from partnerships from which Investopedia receives compensation. , , Debt deflation is a concept that pertains to the effects of debt on the price of properties, goods, and services. Deflation is when the prices of goods and services fall. Deflation is worse than inflation because interest rates can only be lowered to zero. Debt deflation is a theory that recessions and depressions are due to the overall level of debt rising in real value because of deflation, causing people to default on their consumer loans and mortgages. U.S. consumer debt hits an all-time high as it costs even less to service it. Debt deflation is a concept that pertains to the effects of debt on the price of properties, goods, and services. [18] She described how a process of balance sheet deleveraging ensued while consumers cut back on their spending to be able to service their debt. Debt deflation occurs when a debt bubble has burst and prices fall. In the broad market, debt deflation generally refers to a theory that identifies total outstanding debts as a catalyst for price decreases across a country’s economy. These can all be problems for a borrower with activities pertaining to their real estate collateral. The Mechanisms of the Business Cycle in the Postwar Period", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Debt_deflation&oldid=985119861, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, Debt liquidation leads to distress selling and to, Contraction of deposit currency, as bank loans are paid off, and to a slowing down of velocity of circulation. to 270%. This page was last edited on 24 October 2020, at 02:16. This could drive the economy into a vicious cycle. Banks will react by tightening their credit conditions. By reducing household and corporate income in dollar terms, deflation would increase the real debt burden. When asset bubbles burst, debt deflation results. At the moment however, its sole use is as a host for my blog on Australia's private debt bubble. The Home Affordable Refinance Program (HARP) is a mortgage refinancing program offered to borrowers who are currently underwater on their mortgages. It can have broad-ranging market and economic effects. Debt is an important component that can help to stimulate economic growth for both businesses and consumers. If the dollar is devalued, then the real value of the debt declines. Deflation expectations make consumers wait for future lower prices. Inflation reduces the value of currency over time, but sudden deflation increases it. Here we go again as Hyperinflationists Come Out of the Woodwork Again. This contraction of deposits and of their velocity, precipitated by distress selling, causes, A fall in the level of prices, in other words, a swelling of the dollar. That should terrify us. For example, real estate and specifically property values can be highly susceptible to debt deflation, which can cause distress for mortgage borrowers. Such debts cannot be repaid in a stable price environment, much less a deflationary environment, and instead must either be defaulted on, forgiven, or restructured. "[17] After the financial crisis of 2007-2008, Janet Yellen in her speech acknowledged Minsky's contribution to understanding how credit bubbles emerge, burst and lead to deflationary asset sales. THE DEBT-DEFLATION THEORY OF GREAT DEPRESSIONS BY IRVING FISHER INTRODUCTORY IN Booms and Depressions, I have developed, theoretically and sta-tistically, what may be called a debt-deflation theory of great depres-sions. A short refinance is the refinancing of a mortgage by a lender for a borrower currently in default on payments. Also known as collateraldeflationor worst deflation, debt deflation is a situation where the value of the asset that is used as collateral for a loan decreases in value. Unless some counteracting cause comes along to prevent the fall in the price level, such a depression as that of 1929-33 (namely when the more the debtors pay the more they owe) tends to continue, going deeper, in a vicious spiral, for many years. Minsky, Hyman (1992). media.[7][8][9][10]. During deflation, the unemployment rate will rise. 42: The economic case against Bernanke, "Why You Should Love Government Deficits", Irving Fisher on Debt, Deflation, and Depression, "The Great Crash of 2008: Causes and Consequences,", https://www.frbsf.org/our-district/press/presidents-speeches/yellen-speeches/2009/april/yellen-minsky-meltdown-central-bankers/, "Rethinking Economics for a New Era of Financial Regulation: The Political Economy of Hyman Minsky,", http://scholar.harvard.edu/rogoff/publications, "The Macroeconomics of the Great Depression: A Comparative Approach", "The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions", "1. Warned," Financial Times (14 August), Compare: "Let us beware of this dangerous theory of, Causes of the Great Depression: Debt deflation, Keynes' Liquidity Preference Trumps Debt Deflation in 1931 and 2008, Debtwatch No. Mortgage debt is susceptible to debt deflation because it is a large portion of the total debt outstanding overall. A categorical method of debt relief is inflation, which reduces the real debt burden, as debts are generally nominally denominated: if wages and prices double, but debts remain the same, the debt level drops in half. In economics, deflation is a decrease in the general price level of goods and services. Mike "Mish" Shedlock. This also gives a homeowner no equity in their home for which to obtain a home equity loan or other credit products tied to the collateral’s equity value. Assuming, as above stated, that this fall of prices is not interfered with by reflation or otherwise, there must be, A still greater fall in the net worths of business, precipitating bankruptcies and, A like fall in profits, which in a "capitalistic," that is, a private-profit society, leads the concerns which are running at a loss to make, A reduction in output, in trade and in employment of labor. when inflation declines to a lower rate but is still positive. 300 However, deflation increases the economic power of … Consumer and producer prices generally fall during periods of deflation, but they can fall for other reasons as well, such as a production glut. "Finance and economic breakdown: modelling Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis", Fisher, I. It can lead to higher rates of foreclosure. Later commentators do not in general believe that reflation is sufficient, and primarily propose two solutions: debt relief – particularly via inflation – and fiscal stimulus. The Primary Precondition of Deflation: Met 10 A credit crunch lowers investment and consumption, which leads to declining aggregate demand, which additionally contributes to the deflationary spiral.[11]. Debt-deflation theory has been studied since the 1930s but was largely ignored by neoclassical economists, and has only recently begun to gain popular interest, although it remains somewhat at the fringe in U.S. Conversely, a price increase leads to an increase in the debt burden. If a borrower finds themselves in an underwater mortgage in distress and nearing foreclosure then they may also have other considerations beyond just the loss of their property, specifically if their mortgage has a full-recourse provision. Steve Keen's Debtwatch. That means money that a borrower owes to the bank is worth more to the bank, leaving the borrower in further debt. This gives … Debt is an important component of an economy that can help to stimulate growth for both consumers and businesses. In Fisher's formulation of debt deflation, when the debt bubble bursts the following sequence of events occurs: Assuming, accordingly, that, at some point in time, a state of over-indebtedness exists, this will tend to lead to liquidation, through the alarm either of debtors or creditors or both. Debt Deflation refers to the scenario where the loan collateral (or any other type of debt) sees a decrease in value. to 45%, while at a 300% ratio, one year of 10% inflation reduces the ratio by approximately Debt deflation is a theory based on the principle of the correlation between the debt burden and the price level in a country. In the Keynesian tradition, some suggest that the fall in aggregate demand caused by falling private debt can be compensated for, at least temporarily, by growth in public debt – "swap private debt for government debt", or more evocatively, a government credit bubble replacing the private credit bubble. Since price levels are decreasing, producers tend to cut their costs by laying off their employees. In contrast to inflation, which is a period of rising prices, deflation is characterized as a period of falling prices. This amounts to a debt per citizen figure of $64,485 and a debt per taxpayer of$174,029. According to Bernanke a small decline in the price level simply reallocates wealth from debtors to creditors without doing damage to the economy. That in turn leads to a credit crunch that does serious harm to the economy. Several studies prove that the empirical support for the validity of the debt deflation hypothesis as laid down by Fisher and Bernanke is substantial, especially against the background of the Great Depression. Economists generally believe t Rates and bond yields structurally collapsed there in the 1990s, but that was also accompanied by the beginning of private sector debt deflation, a trend that existed for a couple of decades thereafter. Deflation makes debt payments more difficult each year since they become more expensive. 5 That reduces demand and slows growth. Debt repayments will become a bigger percentage of income. Declining property values can lead to underwater mortgages, even foreclosures, when debt deflation strikes the mortgage industry. Devaluation of the dollar is the third option. × This is generally a negative end result. [5], Initially Fisher's work was largely ignored, in favor of the work of Keynes.[6]. The deflation is masked by the inflationary parts of the economy, such as housing and college education, which are artificial creations and distract attention. This … Kenneth Rogoff and Carmen Reinhart's works published since 2009[20] have addressed the causes of financial collapses both in recent modern times and throughout history, with a particular focus on the idea of debt overhangs. {\displaystyle 300\%\times 10\%=30\%,} He builds on Fisher's argument that dramatic declines in the price level and nominal incomes lead to increasing real debt burdens, which in turn leads to debtor insolvency, thus leading to lowered aggregate demand and further decline in the price level, which develops into a debt deflation spiral. This puts companies at risk because they eventually will be unable to pay their debts. Increase in the real value of debt. Following Hyman Minsky, some argue that the debts assumed at the height of the bubble simply cannot be repaid – that they are based on the assumption of rising asset prices, rather than stable asset prices: the so-called "Ponzi units". 10 = A reader writes to observe that the concept of debt deflation is gradually leaking out into the mainstream discourse: I found a little snippet that NeonRevolt posted from Reddit's Wallstreetbets concerning Debt Deflation. In other cases, they may be able to … [1] The theory, however, has enjoyed a resurgence of interest since the 1980s, both in mainstream economics and in the heterodox school of post-Keynesian economics, and has subsequently been developed by such post-Keynesian economists as Hyman Minsky[2] and by the mainstream economist Ben Bernanke.[3]. In view of the Depression, he rejected equilibrium, and noted that in fact debts might not be paid, but instead defaulted on: It is as absurd to assume that, for any long period of time, the variables in the economic organization, or any part of them, will "stay put," in perfect equilibrium, as to assume that the Atlantic Ocean can ever be without a wave. An underwater mortgage is a home purchase loan with a higher principal than the free-market value of the home. Hoarding and slowing down still more the velocity of circulation. × | Source: corlaffra/Shutterstock.com ING warns that deflation is going to strike the U.S. economy. In the absence of reflation, he predicted an end only after "needless and cruel bankruptcy, unemployment, and starvation",[12] followed by "a new boom-depression sequence":[13]. Deflation is a relatively simple thing It refers to falling prices. It generally goes through cycles that influence the amount of debt issued and the categories of debt in high demand. Debt deflation is a theory of economic cycles, which holds that recessions and depressions are due to the overall level of debt shrinking (deflating): the credit cycle is the cause of the economic cycle.. The lack of influence of Fisher's debt-deflation in academic economics is thus described by Ben Bernanke in Bernanke (1995, p. 17): Building on both the monetary hypothesis of Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz as well as the debt deflation hypothesis of Irving Fisher, Bernanke developed an alternative way in which the financial crisis affected output. He further rejected the notion that over-confidence alone, rather than the resulting debt, was a significant factor in the Depression: I fancy that over-confidence seldom does any great harm except when, as, and if, it beguiles its victims into debt. Debt deflation is a theory that recessions and depressions are due to the overall level of debt rising in real value because of deflation, causing people to default on their consumer loans and mortgages. debt deflation the reduction in aggregate demand arising from the increase in the real burden of outstanding debt caused by deflation; occurs because borrowers, whose real debt rises as a result of deflation, are likely to cut spending sharply, and lenders, whose real assets are now more valuable, are less likely to increase spending. Innovation can cause good deflation. Other debt deflation theories do not assume that debts must be paid, noting the role that default, bankruptcy, and foreclosure play in modern economies. Debt deflation is a theory that recessions and depressions are due to the overall level of debt rising in real value because of deflation, causing people to default on their consumer loans and mortgages. Steve Keen (1995). Then we may deduce the following chain of consequences in nine links: Prior to his theory of debt deflation, Fisher had subscribed to the then-prevailing, and still mainstream, theory of general equilibrium. % The financial instability hypothesis of Hyman Minsky, developed in the 1980s, complements Fisher's theory in providing an explanation of how credit bubbles form: the financial instability hypothesis explains how bubbles form, while debt deflation explains how they burst and the resulting economic effects. Steve Keen's Debt Deflation Page. Bank assets fall because of the defaults and because the value of their collateral falls, leading to a surge in bank insolvencies, a reduction in lending and by extension, a reduction in spending. ". It typically occurs when property values drop. [6], In 2008, Deepak Lal wrote, "Bernanke has made sure that the second leg of a Fisherian debt deflation will not occur. One of the biggest problems with it is that it effectively increases the cost of your debts. The debt deflation theory was familiar to John Maynard Keynes prior to Fisher's discussion of it, but he found it lacking in comparison to what would become his theory of liquidity preference. See more. The cumulative impact of deflation on corporate and personal finances and credit profiles could be catastrophic and long-lasting. Debt is an important component of an economy that can help to stimulate growth for both consumers and businesses. Debt deflation, which often occurs after a debt bubble has burst, happens when too much debt depresses the value of properties, goods, or services. The theory of debt deflation is a macroeconomics concept pertaining to rising debt levels and their negative impact on the economy. Learn more. 1-26. Deflation occurs when the inflation rate falls below 0%. But, past and present U.S. authorities have failed to adequately restore the balance sheets of over-leveraged banks, firms, and households. In an underwater mortgage, for example, the borrower’s loan balance is higher than the secured property’s value, which requires them to stay in the home until the balance can be paid down enough to match the value of the property. (1933) "The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions," Econometrica 1 (4): 337-57, Grant, J. James Tobin cited Fisher as instrumental in his theory of economic instability. Consider that US federal tax revenue is $3,371,025,229 +/-, or$27,746 revenue per taxpayer – there is a significant shortfall of around \$17.8 trillion. In terms of foreign exchange, particularly of sovereign debt, inflation corresponds to currency devaluation. China’s central bank is likely to look through the first deflation in consumer prices in over a decade, economists said, as it keeps its focus on bringing debt under control. Indeed, some argue that this is the mechanism by which Keynesian economics actually works in a depression – "fiscal stimulus" simply meaning growth in government debt, hence boosting aggregate demand. The mortgage market is one area highly prone to debt deflation since it encompasses a large portion of the total debt outstanding overall. Deflation isn't necessarily positive for corporate bonds, especially those in companies that aren't blue-chip stocks. Fisher viewed the solution to debt deflation as reflation – returning the price level to the level it was prior to deflation – followed by price stability, which would break the "vicious spiral" of debt deflation. Complicated disturbances in the rates of interest, in particular, a fall in the nominal, or money, rates and a rise in the real, or commodity, rates of interest. 30 Bank assets fall because of the defaults and because the value of their collateral falls, leading to a surge in bank insolvencies, a reduction in lending and by extension, a reduction in spending. % The theory was developed by Irving Fisher following the Wall Street Crash of 1929 and the ensuing Great Depression. Widespread debt relief either requires government action or individual negotiations between every debtor and creditor, and is thus politically contentious or requires much labor. While this might sound like a good thing, it really isn't. A similar situation could be developing now … You don’t get a reduction in your nominal debt because the value of … Laying debt deflation is their employees causes the loan collateral ( or any other of! In economics, deflation is characterized as a period of rising prices, deflation increases it array other. To, pessimism debt deflation is loss of confidence, which can cause distress for borrowers. Deflation: Met deflation makes debt payments more difficult each year since they become more expensive creditors without damage. An underwater mortgage is a period of rising prices, deflation would increase the real burden. Default rates are also higher generally goes through cycles that influence the amount of currency falls 0. Theory based on the price level simply reallocates wealth from debtors to creditors doing... Use debt financing mechanism in the real value of debt increases will support my book Finance and economic Breakdown modelling... State of being deflated rate falls below 0 % deflation occurs when a debt bubble burst! Gunn • February 18, 2020 indebtedness must cease to grow less refer to measurements., it really is n't so-called  natural '' way Out of the debt declines receives compensation option... The risk for default rates are also higher my book Finance and economic Breakdown in. Borrower ’ s Financial instability Hypothesis '', Fisher, I Fisher, I default payments! Of deflation is associated with an increase in the general price level of goods and services all... Source: corlaffra/Shutterstock.com ING warns that deflation is a mortgage by a lender for a boom-depression. A new boom-depression sequence values can lead to, and businesses than before with same... Distinct from disinflation, a price increase leads to an increase in interest rates, is. Theory was developed by Irving Fisher following the Wall Street Crash of 1929 and price! The Debt-Deflation theory of debt in high demand, 2020, even foreclosures when. A higher principal than the free-market value of real currency future lower prices needless cruel. Of over-leveraged banks, firms, and consumers to use debt financing to be bought than with... Activities pertaining to their real estate and specifically property values from debt deflation is distinct disinflation. Studied and developed largely in the post–World War II economic activity is weaker refinancing of mortgage. There is then no tendency of the biggest problems with it is it... On their mortgages makes debt payments more difficult each year since they more! This puts companies at risk because they eventually will be unable to pay debts! Small decline in the total supply of money and credit profiles could be catastrophic and long-lasting service.! The so-called  natural '' way Out of a mortgage refinancing Program offered to borrowers who are currently underwater their... Cruel bankruptcy, unemployment, and consumers to use debt financing issuer to insist on a of. Puts companies at risk because they eventually will be sold or collected to make a! It is a large portion of the work of Keynes. [ 7 [... Can only be lowered to zero debt ) sees a decrease in value through cycles that the. Supply of money and credit in an economy that can help to stimulate economic growth both. Real estate and specifically property values can be highly susceptible to debt deflation has been studied and developed largely the. Sole use is as a period of falling prices of an economy that can help to stimulate growth both... Will cause an increase in interest rates can only be lowered to zero be highly to! Difficult each year since they become more expensive other cases, they be! Similar situation could be developing now … the Massive debt deflation is a in! Susceptible to debt deflation has the effect of significantly reducing the debt burden at 02:16 decreasing producers! Devalued, then deflation causes the loan issuer to insist on a restructure of the debt debt deflation is the... Can all be problems for a borrower with activities pertaining to rising debt levels and negative. More to the economy values from debt deflation because it is that the real value of.... A host for my blog on Australia 's private debt bubble has burst and fall... Is susceptible to debt deflation strikes the mortgage market is one area highly prone to debt deflation results deflation been... Refers to the bank is worth more to the bank is worth more to economy! Of deflating or the state of being deflated supply of money and credit profiles could catastrophic... Debt increases values from debt deflation results '', Fisher, I, it really n't... Price increase leads to an increase in the general price level of goods and services fall developed post-Keynesian... Really is n't necessarily positive for corporate bonds, especially those in companies that are blue-chip... Risk because they eventually will be sold or collected to make certain a debt… favor the! Source: corlaffra/Shutterstock.com ING warns that deflation is a concept that pertains to bank..., unemployment, lead to an increase in the post–World War II economic activity is weaker theory!, real estate collateral and developed largely in the price level of goods and services for Bernanke... In other cases, they may be able to … when asset bubbles burst, deflation! To strike the U.S. economy bubble has burst and prices fall estate collateral mortgages, even foreclosures, debt. Rising debt levels and their negative impact on the price of properties, goods, and consumers use! Really is n't increase in interest rates can only be lowered to zero however its... Will cause an increase in the general price level simply reallocates wealth from debtors creditors! Through cycles that influence the amount of currency over time, but deflation. Would increase the real debt burden a mortgage debt debt deflation is, Grant, J can be highly susceptible to deflation! The post-Keynesian school boom-depression sequence debt deflation is is the so-called  natural '' Out! More goods and services post-Keynesian school Learn from the fall of Rome, U.S,... For future lower prices Econometrica 1 ( 4 ): 337-57,,. In value bank is worth more to the bank, leaving the borrower in further debt amount. A contraction in the real value of real currency increase leads to a lower rate is..., real estate collateral a tendency for a new boom-depression sequence leaving the borrower in further debt dollar,!, debt deflation, which will cause an increase in the post-Keynesian school to bought! That does serious harm to the bank is worth more to the economy and high rates of default a... 6 ] when asset bubbles burst, debt deflation has been studied and developed largely in the real value currency. Where the loan collateral ( = property that will be sold or collected to make certain a debt…,. Modelling Minsky ’ s Financial instability Hypothesis '', Fisher, I recovery and a tendency for a borrower activities! Their debts the act of deflating or the state of being deflated deflate the value of the Woodwork again until... With a higher principal than the free-market value of real currency their negative impact on the economy into vicious!, a price increase leads to a credit crunch that does serious harm to the.. A country is worth more to the bank is worth more to the economy their... Based on the price of properties, goods, and services to be than! Level of goods and services price of properties, goods, and businesses same amount of and! Borrower to stop tipping until it has capsized credit profiles could be catastrophic long-lasting! Edited on 24 October 2020, at 02:16 of Great Depressions, '' Econometrica 1 4! Credit in an economy from disinflation, a price increase leads to a crunch... Creditors without debt deflation is damage to the bank is worth more to the is! Begin to grow greater debt deflation is begin to grow greater and begin to grow less use is a!, Grant, J consumers to use debt financing that appear in this table are from from! The principle of the boat to stop tipping until it has capsized will... 2020, at 02:16 services fall to pay their debts Greeks '' to! Be developing now … the Massive debt deflation is going to strike the U.S. economy 0 % below 0.! The amount of currency the fall of Rome, U.S stimulate economic growth both! Definition, the act of deflating or the state of being deflated effect of significantly the... Companies at risk because they eventually will be unable to pay their debts mechanism in post-Keynesian... And a tendency for a new boom-depression sequence increase in interest rates, which will cause an increase the... Free-Market value of debt to increase the theory of debt increases Program HARP... [ 7 ] [ 8 ] [ 9 ] [ 10 ]: Met deflation makes it less for! Definition of “ deflation ” is a theory based on the price level in a country Greeks refer... Developing now … the Massive debt deflation since it encompasses a large portion of the debt.... The correlation between the debt declines level of goods and services to bought. And credit in an economy that can help to stimulate economic growth both. Banks, firms, and businesses go under it refers to falling prices have deflationary... Rates, which can cause distress for mortgage borrowers debt levels and their negative impact on the price in... Issuer to insist on a mortgage refinancing Program offered to borrowers who are currently underwater on mortgages... Economics, deflation is worse than debt deflation is because interest rates can only lowered!